Take
any measure and juggle the figures, change the basis of
comparison—no matter what you do, it would come out that
India has one of the most privatised healthcare systems in
the world. Pakistan is a constant companion in this club,
along with countries like Burundi, Ivory Coast, Laos and
Congo.
If you take public expenditure on health as a
percentage of GDP, in India it is a mere 0.9%, among the
lowest in the world and ahead of only four
countries—Burundi, Myanmar, Pakistan, Guinea and Laos.
If you take the share of the government in total
health expenditure, India figures at the bottom of the pile,
with government spending accounting for just 25% of the
total health spend in the country. The only other countries
with lower public health expenditure are Burundi (8%),
Pakistan (16%), Laos (19%), Congo (19%), Cameroon (21%) and
Ivory Coast (24%). The share of government in health
spending varies from 76% in Europe to 34% in Southeast Asia.
India’s spending plummets below the lowest even in
this range.
If you were to consider the share of health
expenditure in total government expenditure,
India again has among the lowest proportions in the world a
mere 3.4%. Only Pakistan (1.3%) and Burundi (2.3%) allocate
a lower portion of total expenditure
on
health.
In India, private spending on health is 4.2% of
GDP. More than 70% of all health expenditure in India is
paid for by people from their own pockets and this
expenditure has been rising, especially for the poorest with
privatisation of healthcare increasing.
According to a Planning Commission paper of May
2009, several studies conducted in villages showed that
healthcare expense was responsible for over half of all the
cases of decline into poverty. It is estimated that in
2004-05, an additional 39 million people were pushed into
poverty due to out-ofpocket payments.
Drugs eat up 80% spending of people
Astudy has revealed that India has one of the most
privatised healthcare
systems in the world, along with Pakistan, Burundi, Ivory
Coast, Laos and Congo.
N S S O data for
2004-05 shows that of the total medical expenditure per
capita, medicines alone accounted for 74% of the expenses in
rural areas and 67% in urban areas. If we were to consider
only non-institutional medical care, which constitutes the
bulk of health expenses, drugs constitute over 80% of
peoples expenditure, indicating the huge impact rising drug
prices have on health expenditure. However, while most
countries around the world, including the capitalist
democracies, have drug price control measures of some kind
or the other, India is under pressure to remove whatever
meagre control it has over drug pricing.
Increasing privatisation over the past few years
has led to cost escalation in healthcare that has pushed
more and more people into poverty. Though the National Rural
Health Mission (NRHM) is making a difference, it has a long
way to go before it shows any results. Moreover, it is only
for the rural areas and mostly for primary health.
Secondary- and tertiary-level care continues to be
expensive, says Dr Selvaraj Sakthivel of the Public Health
Foundation of India.