|
Title:
Progress towards Millennium
Development Goals- Study of Selected Asian
Countries
Author:
Sumati Kulkarni &
Babu Santosh Kumar
This
paper examines the progress of Asian countries
towards the first seven Millennium Development
goals—(poverty eradication, universal primary
education, gender equality, reduction in child
mortality, improvement in maternal health,
combating HIV/AIDS, Malaria and other diseases,
ensuring environmental sustainability) and
highlights the issues and concerns in this
respect.
Objectives
of the paper are:
1.
To review the performance of major Asian countries
regarding the progress towards the seven goals and
bring out the variations within the region.
2.
To examine the linkages between different
performance indicators.
3.
To analyze the determinants of the major impact
indicators and identify the critical inputs
required for accelerating their progress towards
specific goals.
Analysis pertains to 17 countries
viz. China, Japan, Republic of Korea, Malaysia,
Thailand, Philippines, Vietnam, Singapore,
Indonesia, Sri Lanka, India, Pakistan, Bangladesh
and Nepal. For comparability, the analysis is
based on data from only one source i.e. World Bank
Publication – World Development Indicators 2006.
Data on 31 indicators used to monitor the progress
towards seven goals are analyzed. Average rank is
calculated for each country to summarize its
relative position based on its performance
regarding the various indicators is used to make
inter-country comparisons. Correlations are
examined to study the linkages. Regression
analyses are carried out with one indicator for
each goal as the dependent variable to identify
critical inputs to accelerate the progress towards
specific goals. Independent variables include
background variables such as population, GNP,
adult literacy, percentage urban, electricity
consumption and a few input variables specific to
that particular goal e.g. health expenditure per
capita, doctor population ratio, access to safe
water for mortality reduction goal, expenditure on
education, teacher pupil ratio for universal
primary education goal etc.
The main findings from the
analysis reveal that:
1. Malaysia, Korea and Thailand
with less than 2% of its population below the
international poverty line are likely to eradicate
poverty soon, while India and Bangladesh are far
behind with one third of their population below
the poverty line. China, which in the year 2000
had 17 percent of its population living on less
than $ 1 per capita per day, is progressing fast.
2. Overall performance based on
ranking for 31 indicators identifies Bangladesh,
India, Nepal and Pakistan as poorly performing
countries.
3. Strong linkages are found
between performance towards poverty eradication
goal, universal primary education goal, mortality
reduction goal and gender inequality goal as shown
by high significant correlations in the expected
direction.
For Full Paper reference, contact the author on
the e-mail id:
sumatik@vsnl.com
Title:
Improving
Rural Sanitation: Results of Randomized
Information, Education and Communication Campaign
from Orissa
Author: Subhrendu
Pattanayak, Jonathan Blitstein, Jui-Chen Yang,
Sumeet Patil, Katherine Dickinson, Kelly Jones,
Christine Poulos, Purujit Praharaj & Ranjan
Mallick
To
present the study design and preliminary findings
of a randomized controlled intervention to
increase the availability and use of individual
household latrines (IHL) in the state of Orissa,
India.
Cluster-randomized controlled trial
with repeated measures on households and
communities. The sample included 40
representative villages from a sampling frame of
1112 villages in the district of Bhadrak. Under
random assignment, 20 villages received an
information, education, and communication (IEC)
campaign and the remaining villages served as
controls. The IEC intervention employed a
participatory approach to social mobilization, in
which trained facilitators worked with
village-level water and sanitation committees to
heighten awareness of sanitation problems, educate
village members about potential solutions, and
empower community-driven action. Data collection
from key informants in each of the 40 villages and
approximately 25 households per village was
secured through the use of local enumerators
trained by our research staff. Across the 40
villages, community-level data was gathered pre-
and post-intervention. In addition, 1086
households (treatment = 534, control = 552) were
surveyed in August/September 2005; the same set of
households will be surveyed in the coming month.
Finally, a series of semi-structured interviews
was conducted in 10 of the 40 study villages
post-intervention to supplement the quantitative
dataset with more qualitative accounts of
individuals’ sanitation behaviors and attitudes.
Respondents who self-identified as the primary
care giver of a child below the age of 5 years
provided data for the household survey. Key
informants provided information on village
infrastructure and characteristics. A selection of
men, women, and children participated in informal
discussions in the 10 villages selected for
additional qualitative fieldwork.
Baseline findings suggest that
randomization successfully distributed potential
confounders across experimental conditions; some
differences across condition are identified and
these will be controlled for analytically in the
impact analyses. Preliminary analysis of the
community-level dataset suggest that the IEC
intervention has had a significant impact on the
adoption and, to a lesser extent, use of IHL in
the villages subject to this intervention.
Qualitative results confirm that village members
in IEC villages were aware of the intervention and
that a process of sanitation-related behaviour
change may be underway. Demand for IHL is present
to varying degrees in both treatment and control
villages, although we also identify persistent
barriers to widespread adoption and use.
The
ongoing Orissa evaluation suggests that intensive
IEC campaigns of the kind implemented in the 20
treatment villages in this study may provide an
effective catalyst for sanitary latrine adoption
and use. However, this study also highlights many
of the difficulties associated with effecting
lasting and widespread behaviour change. The
practice of open defecation is a long-standing
institution in the villages we study, and
replacing this institution with a new behavioral
norm requires overcoming a number of barriers
affecting both supply and demand factors. This
process of social change is likely to take time,
suggesting the need for ongoing study over a
longer follow-up period.
For
Full Paper reference, contact the author on the
e-mail id: subhrendu@rti.org
|